
I first saw
Over the Rhine perform in August of ought-four at the
Glen Workshop in Santa Fe. They were promoting their double album
OHIO, and I was moved in a way that I hadn't been by music in quite some time. (Actually, something must have been going on that summer as I had the experience twice in a short span--with OTR and a Sam Phillips show in Chicago.) In the 15 or so months since that first experience, I've now seen the group perform a total of five times: two Glen appearances, a festival in Bowling Green, a show in Columbus this past September, and this Friday last in a tiny little country opera house in Bellville, OH.
The Bellville Opera House is housed on the second floor of the town hall. There's no signs to speak of; I drove past the place twice looking for it. The only restrooms are entered from outside the building on the ground floor. In fact, I'm convinced that the show was so short precisely because there was no backstage to speak of, and, as Karin informed us, no bathrooms. The floors look like original wood. The walls are painted white with gray insets of trim. The stage is set about four feet off the ground and, off to the right, has a set of wooden steps leading to a door with a door knocker. This is the only entrance to the wings. In many ways, it reminds me of the stage at my high school, which was housed in an old elementary school.

It's obvious that what keeps the old Opera House going is the people of
Highlands of Ohio, a local group interested in promoting Celtic and other traditional music. While the venue is most definitely old, it is very well maintained. Walking into the room, I was immediately offered a wide variety of hors douerves, coffee, and hot cider that was all being provided free of charge. Children, grandparents, teenagers, and a small cadre of OTR junkies milled around the small CD table. There were only about 100 or so chairs set up, and they just about took up all the available space. (Side note: I wondered the whole night about the economics of the show. Even with a sell-out [which it wasn't], the total gate receipts couldn't have been more than $1500-1800. Given that OTR had their full lineup (Karin, Linford, Kim Taylor, plus a drummer and a guitar/bass player) I have a hard time believing they would play for only that much. Of course, they were just coming off a Kent State festival and were playing Calvin College the next night, so maybe they just needed to fill a spot on the calendar. Still...)
Unlike the Little Brothers show in Columbus where the venue obviously wanted us to buy copious amounts of beverage, the show kicked off right on time with a small set by the rail thin, brown haired, powerfully voiced, guitar thrashing
Kim Taylor. I was much more impressed with her performance this time through. Perhaps it was the fact that she did the whole thing with her acoustic guitar; in Columbus, she wailed on a helpless little electric that seemed to have offended her in some way. Even though this Florida girl has lived in Cinncinatti for a good long while now, Taylor did reveal that somewhere around midwinter she still gets angry that that she's cold. The story would set up a refrain for the night: musicians kvetching about being cold. Of course, Taylor's website does list some tenative titles for her new record as "I Feel Like a Piece of Shit Because of this Damn Cold" and "95 Things You Should Do That Really Won't Help Get You Over a Bad Cold Faster." So perhaps this has been a theme for a while. As for Taylor's tunes, think of a mix of blues and folk, with a good dash of anger thrown in. Perhaps the stand out tune was the song "Hit Me" about a woman standing up to her abusive partner. I also got a kick out of the tune that declared that she had 95 Things to say to someone. Who can resist a Martin Luther reference?

After a short break, OTR entered through a side door of the venue and climbed the stairs to the stage. Everyone was bundled up in winter coats (someone was in an army green number with a fur-like edging around the hood that caused flashbacks to second grade). I suppose the fact that I was comfortable should have been a clue that everyone else was going to be chilly, but I did think that Linford's and guitarist's hats which they wore through the whole night were a bit much.
Having now seen them five times in a somewhat short period of time, one thing I'll say for Over the Rhine: they do a nice job of changing up the setlist. Sure, they played a good number of tunes from
DRUNKARD'S PRAYER as is right and proper when touring in support of an album. But I have yet to go to a show where I didn't hear at least one or two tunes that I hadn't heard before. This time around, they opened up with "Drunkard's Prayer" and "I Want You To Be My Love." They then went into an extensive version of "Little Blue River," a nice gospel number that gave the band some space to stretch out and jam a bit. I was particularly pleased by the inclusion of "ETC. Whatever." Kim Taylor joined the group for some rollicking versions of "Spark" and "Lookin Forward."

Apart from excellent tunes and great musicianship, I really enjoy the banter between Karin and Linford. It's slightly off-kilter and makes you feel like you're sitting around the table with them drinking coffee. There's jokes and conversation between them, a bit of that "Oh, should I tell them about..." "Sure, go ahead." About midway through the set, the band left the stage and Karin started riffing a bit about how much she liked the songs of
Cole Porter and that her other favorite songwriter is Linford. She then revealed that after 9 years of marriage she still finds her husband to be incredibly sexy, and began playing a song that had been a belated birthday present for Linford this year. Looking at some message boards, I find that the song made its debut just a couple of weeks ago in a series of Dayton shows. At any rate, the song "Trouble" with the line "Baby if you're here to make trouble, make mine a double" is certainly the kind of smouldering torch song that would make Cole Porter proud.

A few songs later, the group closed down the main set with "Cruel and Pretty." As they entered the wings, the side door out into the venue opened and closed once or twice. I'm guessing they were deciding whether they could dash out for a bathroom break because when they did--inevitably--return to the stage Karin informed us that "You knew we were coming back. There's nowhere for us to go back here. And we all really need to use a bathroom."
All in all, the show was precisely what I've come to enjoy about OTR: well-crafted songs performed with passion. Linford, despite the chill, kept the keys warm all night and wowed the crowd with some fantastic solo work. (He also displayed his versatility by also taking turns on guitar and bass.) Karin, with a scarf wrapped around her neck protecting those supple vocal cords, loosed her lythe voice upon this small group in a small venue in a small town with as much verve and skill as she does in a crowded theatre or at a gathering of artistic peers.
Setlist:
Bellville Opera House
November 18, 2005

Drunkard's Prayer
I Want You To Be My Love
Little Blue River
Etc. Whatever
What I'll Remember Most
Suitcase*
Born*
Spark*
Lookin Forward*
Little Did I Know
Trouble
Show Me
Cruel and Pretty
_____________________
Firefly
When I Go
*w/Kim Taylor